On September 1, 2021, market contributors should shell out extra for margins because the fourth section of SEBI’s most margin guidelines come into impact. Below the foundations, brokers will now be required to obtain the complete margin payable by the consumer earlier than the tip of the buying and selling session.
For instance, if the relevant margin on a specific transaction is 30 p.c of the worth of the transaction, the complete 30 p.c would have to be deposited by the client. The motive behind SEBI’s choice is to curb extreme hypothesis and make sure that the settlement system will not be threatened by dealer failures. The strict requirements additionally imply that brokers will not have the ability to use one consumer’s funds to fulfill one other consumer’s margin necessities.
Commodity market brokers imagine the brand new guidelines might damage buying and selling volumes for a lot of smaller buying and selling corporations as their shoppers reduce on trades resulting from elevated margin necessities.
Beforehand, margins had been collected prematurely and calculated primarily based on positions on the finish of the day. The dealer funded the shoppers’ intraday positions so long as they introduced within the excellent quantity on the finish of the day.
The brand new guidelines pressure the trade to randomly choose 4 occasions a day to take snapshots of all of the margins, the best margin of which is able to then grow to be the utmost margin.
Learn right here
Consultants level out that the brand new guidelines have largely impacted buying and selling volumes within the commodities phase resulting from its excessive contract worth and main to large margin necessities for merchants.
India’s largest commodity trade, Multi Commodity Change (MCX), mentioned in its current annual report: “There was a decline in buying and selling volumes because the most margin reporting requirement was put in place. implementation and the decline in volumes might additional improve after 100% of the reporting obligations come into pressure.
MCX holds the monopoly on the buying and selling of bullion, base metals and crude oil in India.
As well as, transaction prices are additionally increased, with the commodity transaction tax (TTC) constituting a major half. The excessive value of transactions discourages giant folders like hedgers. Thus, gamers within the commodities market face the double whammy of upper margin necessities and better transaction prices.
“Commodity buying and selling has been affected in current occasions resulting from a variety of components. The Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT), competitors from low cost brokerage corporations and investor attractiveness to the inventory market are a few of these points. On high of that, Sebi’s most margin guidelines hit buying and selling even tougher, ”mentioned Ajay Kedia, Director, Kedia Advisory.
Kedia added that commodity buying and selling is an costly funding. The present margin requirement for buying and selling within the phase is already big. As well as, the extra margin as a result of new rules will end in already lowered volumes.
The rise in margin necessities had an affect on transaction volumes, transaction worth or income was not allotted for this function, consultants mentioned. This is because of a pointy improve within the costs of all commodities, particularly gold, silver and copper.
These guidelines had no affect on the international trade enterprise as such, added Kedia, including that the calculation of international trade charges is finished on the whole turnover which elevated resulting from a pointy rise in commodity costs.
Consultants additionally imagine that whereas the foundations are helpful in the long term, they will encourage “casual” commerce within the brief run.
“Sebi’s new margin guidelines will strengthen capital markets in 6 to eight years. Nevertheless, such an enormous margin requirement and tighter guidelines also can result in transactions in casual setups or unlawful enterprise actions, ”mentioned Amit Sajeja, Vice President, Analysis-Commodities & Currencies, Motilal Oswal.
Sajeja believes that the correct implementation of current rules, strengthening of danger administration, in addition to training and monitoring of brokers must be the precedence.
Stricter requirements have led to a pointy improve in buying and selling volumes within the unlawful or casual market, generally known as Dabba buying and selling.
Usually referred to as an over-the-counter transaction, buying and selling in dabba is estimated at Rs 3 lakh crore per day.
“The transaction volumes within the dabba market have not too long ago elevated as a result of excessive value of transactions within the formal market. final yr, ”mentioned a Mumbai-based dabba dealer.
“The drop in volumes additionally eroded liquidity in formal markets, leading to a larger distinction between the asking worth and the bid worth of the commodity on the terminals. With the CTT and the shortage of leveraged funding, an increasing number of traders are turning to Dabba buying and selling, ”the individual mentioned.
In the meantime, commodity exchanges have not too long ago launched a variety of measures to draw traders and merchants and to reduce the affect of huge margins.
The introduction of commodity indices like MCX Bulldex, MCX Metldex and the upcoming MCX Energdex are all steps in the identical course, Kedia mentioned.
“As well as, commodity buying and selling choices gained floor resulting from decrease margin necessities, much less brokerage and minimal bills. Carrying value and transaction value are additionally low. This introduction of commodity choices buying and selling was a step in the proper course, ”mentioned Kedia.
Exchanges have additionally lowered the lot sizes of some commodities, which is able to assist cut back funding wants for commodity buying and selling, he added.